Key Takeaways
- Put a checkable noun in your headline, not a promise. Who you work with and what you do for them. A sentence that could describe any coach in the country gives an assistant nothing it can repeat about you specifically.
- Make the second sentence narrow the first, never repeat it. Its job is the situation: the stage, the problem, the moment somebody hires you. Most sites waste it restating the headline in different adjectives.
- Spend the third sentence on a fact somebody could verify. A city, a price, a number of years, a specific credential. One verifiable detail early does more for you than three paragraphs of philosophy further down.
- Run the strip test before you publish anything. Cross out every word that could appear on a competitor site. Whatever is still standing is the only part of your sentence that can be quoted about you.
- Write for a stranger who arrived mid-conversation. Assume no context, no logo recognition, and no scrolling. The top of the page has to work alone, because for most readers and most assistants it is all that gets read.
Most homepage rewrites start with the design. New photography, a tidier layout, a color that feels more current. Six weeks later the site looks better and describes the business exactly as vaguely as it did before.
The part that decides whether anything can say a useful sentence about you is much smaller than a redesign. It is three sentences, and they are probably already there.
They are also probably three restatements of the same promise, which is the specific failure this post is about.
Which three sentences does AI read first?
Your main headline, the supporting line directly under it, and the first sentence of your first real paragraph. Those three sit at the top of the readable document, and they are the raw material for any short description of your business.
Fixing them is an afternoon of work, not a project. There is no design change, no new page, and nothing to install.
The test for whether they are working is blunt. Read only those three sentences and ask whether a stranger could now say who you help, what you do about it, and one checkable fact about you. Most sites fail on all three.
Why the top of the page carries the weight
Because summaries get built from openings. Google's own explanation of how snippets are generated describes the process of picking the part of a page that best answers the question at hand, and the top of a document is disproportionately where that lands. The same instinct applies when an assistant compresses your site into one line.
It is also a question of what a summary can afford to include. Whatever is reading you is producing two or three sentences about your business, not twenty, so the material at the top is competing for a very small space. The Princeton generative engine optimization study found that adding specific, citable detail improved how often content was used in generated answers, which is the same finding from the other direction: vagueness does not survive compression.
None of this means the rest of your site is wasted. It means the rest of your site is rarely reached before a description of you has already been formed. How that description gets assigned to a category in the first place is covered in describing what you do so AI categorizes you right.
What each of the three sentences has to do
Each sentence has one job, and the jobs do not overlap. When two of them do the same job, the third one is doing nothing.
| Sentence | Its one job | How it usually fails | What to write instead |
|---|---|---|---|
| The headline | Name who you help and what you do | A promise with no noun in it | Two nouns: the person, and the thing you do for them |
| The supporting line | Narrow it to a situation or stage | Repeats the headline in new adjectives | The moment somebody decides to hire you |
| The first body sentence | Offer one verifiable fact | Starts your origin story | A city, a price, a span of years, a named credential |
The third row is the one people resist hardest. A verifiable fact feels small next to a mission statement, and it is the only one of the three that anything can repeat without hedging.
A headline that survives nothing
Nothing left. Every word describes any coach on earth.
A headline that survives the test
Four facts left: who, what stage, which city, how long.
Same length, same tone, same confidence. One of them says something about a particular business and the other could be pasted onto any site in the field without changing a word.
Both headlines are invented examples written for this figure rather than copy from any client site. Every surviving word shown here is also named in the sections above or in the table.
The three ways these sentences fail
They fail in the same three ways on almost every site, and each has a quick tell.
The headline is a promise with no noun. Unlock your potential. Become the leader you were meant to be. Grow with confidence. The tell is that you could put a competitor logo above it and nothing would look wrong. There is no subject to attach to you.
The supporting line repeats the headline. If the headline says you help leaders grow and the line beneath says you help leaders reach their next level, you have spent your most valuable sentence saying the same thing twice. The tell is that deleting it changes nothing.
The first paragraph starts with you. After fifteen years in corporate life, I realized. It is a fine story and it is in the wrong place, because it arrives before the reader knows whether you are relevant to them. The tell is that the first checkable fact about your business appears below the fold. Why an about page still needs those facts is covered in what a consultant about page needs to earn trust.
How to rewrite all three in an afternoon
Start with the strip test. Write your current headline out and cross out every word that could appear on a competitor site. If nothing survives, you have found the problem and you do not need any further diagnosis.
Then write the headline as a plain statement of who and what, with no adjectives at all. You can add warmth back afterward. Doing it in the other order is how the nouns get lost, every time.
For the supporting line, finish this sentence: people usually come to me when. The answer is a situation, and situations are what buyers actually type. For the third sentence, pick the single most checkable thing about your business and state it flatly. A worked example of these three lines for one specific trade is in what a personal trainer website should say for AI.
One honest limit. Rewriting three sentences will not make an assistant start naming you next week. It changes what can be said about you once something does read the page, which is a prerequisite rather than a result, and it happens to be the cheapest prerequisite on the list.
If you would rather see what is being said about you today before you touch anything, the free check asks ChatGPT 25 real buyer questions from your niche at $0 and emails a plain-English readout. It runs as soon as you ask for it, and the report lands within the hour between 7am and 5pm Central.
Questions we hear the most
Which three sentences on my homepage does AI read first?
Your main headline, the supporting line directly beneath it, and the first sentence of your first real paragraph. Those three sit at the top of the readable document, and they are what a short summary of your business gets built from.
What should my homepage headline say?
Who you work with and what you do for them, in nouns a stranger would recognize. A promise without a noun, such as unlocking potential, cannot be attached to you rather than to anyone else in your field.
What is the strip test for a headline?
Cross out every word in the sentence that could appear on a competitor site. Whatever survives is the only part that identifies you, and a headline where nothing survives cannot be quoted about your business.
Should I put my prices on my homepage?
A price, a range, or a starting figure helps more than it costs. It is checkable, it answers a question every buyer has, and it is one of the few facts that reliably separates you from a generic description.
Does it matter if my headline is an image rather than text?
Yes, and it is worth checking. A headline rendered as an image is a picture of words, so it cannot be read or quoted. Try selecting it with your cursor to find out.
How long should these three sentences be?
Short enough to read in one breath each. Roughly ten to twenty words apiece works well, because a sentence that runs long tends to get cut, and a cut sentence loses the fact you put at the end.
How do I find out what AI currently says about my business?
Ask ChatGPT to describe your business by name in a fresh logged out session, then ask the questions your buyers would ask. Compare what comes back against the three sentences at the top of your homepage.
What does the AnswerHalo free check include?
It asks ChatGPT 25 real buyer questions from your niche and emails you a plain-English report: your score, who got named in your place, and the one fix to start with. It costs $0 and it runs as soon as you ask for it.
Your buyers are already asking. Find out what AI tells them.
The free check asks ChatGPT 25 real buyer questions about your niche and sends you the report within the hour, at $0. If it shows you are already getting named everywhere, we will say so in plain words.
Get my free check →